US road deaths per mile, by named route (2019–2023)

NHTSA FARS deaths on each numbered route, divided by that route’s length in the state from Census TIGER. 800 routes, pooled over 5 years.
Per mile, not per road. By raw count the deadliest US roads are simply the longest busy ones. Dividing by length reorders the list completely — short urban arterials rise, long interstates fall. Both orderings are shown below so the difference is visible.
Per mile is still not per vehicle-mile. It removes the “long roads have more crashes” effect but not the “busy roads have more crashes” one: a rural two-lane at 0.5 deaths/mile is genuinely worse than an interstate at 0.5 carrying twenty times the traffic, and this measure cannot separate them. AADT would; it is not currently obtainable.

Coverage: 75,111 deaths were not on a parseable numbered route (local streets, unnamed roads) and 15,017 were on a route with no TIGER geometry. Neither appears on this map, so it under-counts rather than mis-attributes.

Deadliest routes per mile

#RouteStateDeaths/mile/yr MilesDeaths
1CR-7Illinois1.027526
2US-61Tennessee0.9071360
3SR-45New Mexico0.8421148
4SR-934Florida0.8161353
5CR-21Minnesota0.787520
6CR-1Florida0.766832
7CR-4Minnesota0.6971035
8SR-3007Pennsylvania0.693723
9CR-3Minnesota0.6681136
10CR-6Minnesota0.648620
11SR-1865Kentucky0.609617
12CR-14Minnesota0.593617
13SR-279Georgia0.5881028
14CR-5Minnesota0.586825
15SR-704Florida0.575927
16SR-1001Pennsylvania0.560617
17SR-47South Carolina0.560616
18CR-15Minnesota0.545617
19SR-758Florida0.539615
20CR-35Ohio0.532616
21CR-579Florida0.529616
22SR-1934Kentucky0.517924
23SR-1005Pennsylvania0.508717
24SR-582Florida0.486819
25SR-96Michigan0.4821844
26SR-2009Pennsylvania0.478818
27SR-688Florida0.4761332
28SR-291South Carolina0.4761023
29SR-916Florida0.463818
30SR-30South Carolina0.445715
31SR-686Florida0.435919
32CR-9Minnesota0.4261022
33SR-95Colorado0.4231531
34SR-139Georgia0.4232043
35SR-430Florida0.406511
36SR-65South Carolina0.402714
37SR-932Florida0.3921019
38SR-968Florida0.3911121
39CR-11Minnesota0.388816
40US-78Tennessee0.3882039

…and by raw count, for contrast

RouteStateDeathsMiles Deaths/mile/yr
I-5California7781,6170.096
US-1Florida7049010.156
I-35Texas6631,2300.108
I-95Florida5967860.152
US-41Florida5246210.169
I-45Texas4806170.156
SR-99California4789070.105
I-75Florida4629430.098
I-75Georgia4046940.117
I-15California3826020.127